Thoughts and writings on neuroscience, art, and consciousness from neurologist V.S. Ramachandran.


Crick's PragmatismTuesday, May 31, 2011 7:40 PM

In the next few blogs I'll tell you about some of my early encounters with Francis Crick. Although the quotes are from Crick, it may well be that in some cases he was quoting others. They are also from my memory, which isnt always 100% reliable.

When Crick began his foray into the field of consciousness in the early 1980's he would sometimes give informal seminars on the topic to small groups. I remember one such occasion when Crick had barely started his seminar and a philosopher in the audience raised his hand saying " Dr Crick, what exactly do you MEAN by the word consciousness? Can you first define it before you start talking about it?" Crick's reply was, " No, not at this stage. There was never a time in the history of biology when a group of us sat around the table saying 'Lets first DEFINE life before studying it.' We just went out there and found out what it was—a double helix. We leave matters of semantic hygiene to you philosophers."

Double Helix, by James Gaither
Double Helix, courtesy James Gaither

A pithy way of saying science is an intensely pragmatic affair. Of course it's a good idea to know roughly what you are talking about, but sometimes precise definitions FOLLOW conceptual clarity—not vice versa. Crick's advice is well taken but should not be used as an excuse for shoddy thinking. (I expand on this theme in several endnotes in my new book Tell Tale Brain)

Crick would also often point out that one must scrupulously avoid getting caught up in the elegance or technical sophistication of an experiment; what matters most of all is if you end up proving what you set out to prove: so what?—what is its broader significance? He often quoted someone as having said "If an experiment is not worth doing, it's not worth doing well."

In fact, on one occasion, a rather pedantic experimental psychologist was telling him about a long complicated experiment he had done, incorporating all the proper controls and using considerable technical virtuosity. When he saw Crick's exasperated expression he said "but Dr. Crick, we have got it RIGHT—we know its right," Crick's response was, "The point is not whether it's right. The point is: does it even MATTER whether its right or wrong?"

Here again, that intense pragmatism.

By V.S. Ramachandran. Categories: History, Scientific Method

Comment by Gokul Rajan - Thursday 02nd June 2011 10:19:33 AM

Interesting! Looking forward to learn more crickisms! This blog will help us (me and many more students' like me) to learn how to do science!
Comment by Sean - Thursday 02nd June 2011 05:35:10 PM

I wonder how Crick would have responded to the University of Chicago slogan: "I know it works in practice but what about theory"?

An Introduction to Ramachandran Brain BlogTuesday, May 17, 2011 10:42 PM

Hi guys! This is VS Ramachandran from the Center for Brain and Cognition at UCSD, in La Jolla, California.

I have never blogged before, but have finally decided to bow to the dictates of fashion. I am not entirely sure how its different from just periodic updates on my university website . I guess its meant to have a more informal conversational slant.

Narcissistic reasons aside, what's the purpose of blogging ? Education is one practical goal; the instant dissemination of knowledge. But a more philosophical goal might be that it provides an immortality of sorts—as your mind merges into the world-wide web.

Anyone who has stumbled his/her way into this blog—Ramachandran Blog—probably already knows that I do research on how the human brain works, studying syndromes such as phantom limbs and synesthesia. Much of that has been widely—perhaps too widely—publicized, so I thought I'd talk about something else instead.

I will begin with the late Francis Crick, who had an honorary appointment at our center (in addition to his main appointment at the Salk and adjunct appointment at the UCSD Psychology Department) There's no particular reason for choosing him as a blog topic, he just popped into mind. Perhaps because I often quote his wise and witty maxims at lab meetings and often tell my students "Crick Stories," which deserve to become widely known. And what better vehicle than a blog? (See also my Obituary of Crick, "The Astonishing Francis Crick")

Francis Crick caricature by David Levine
Caricature of Francis Crick by David Levine
Francis Crick's name has become synonymous with modern biology. His discovery of the double helical structure of DNA with Watson, and subsequently the genetic code, marks the birth of molecular biology in the early fifties . Rather late in his career, in the late seventies, I believe, Crick moved permanently from Cambridge to La Jolla. Having solved the riddle of heredity, he set his sights on the next big problem in biology: how the activity of neurons in the brain gives rise to consciousness. (He was joined in this by Christof Koch). At around that time I had been working on human vision and (later) in neurology at Caltech and University of California at Irvine. It so happened, coincidentally, that his two interests at that time were in visual perception and consciousness and so he became instrumental in facilitating my move to the University of California, San Diego. It was a turning point in my career. ( It's astonishing how single individuals can have a huge impact on ones' research style and interests; the other two scientists who influenced me were the late Richard Gregory and Jack Pettigrew). Soon after, the Churchlands and Terry Sejnowski moved to UCSD/Salk; and we were all fortunate, as it soon became the world's leading center for cellular as well as cognitive neuroscience (Gerry Edelman also moved his empire from Rockefeller to La Jolla). La Jolla soon earned the title of the "neuron valley," which, though not matching Silicon Valley in dollar output, quickly outpaced it intellectually in terms of its collective impact in neuroscience (with exceptions like Stanford, maybe?)

Crick and Patricia Churchland and I had lunch at UCSD almost every fortnight during the last three years of his life (except during summer). Pat and I always enjoyed these; we knew we could expect several Crickisms sprinkled among his scientific insights and jokes. He detested pomposity in science and took great delight in deflating self-important individuals, whether face to face or during question time at seminars. In my next blog I'll mention some little known incidents. During his not infrequent visits to my lab he would regale me and my students with 'generic' advice on how to do science. I like to think—at the risk of seeming immodest—that some of his style (but alas not his stature!) rubbed off on us. And we have now been passing these on to the next generation

I'll transmit these to you, dear reader, in my next blog so you can in turn pass them on to several friends, ad infinitum so Crickisms become as immortal as DNA. And if anyone else has stories I invite them to join me.

By V.S. Ramachandran. Categories: History, Scientific Method

Comment by Zack - Wednesday 18th May 2011 04:24:31 AM

I really regret not having had the chance to meet Dr. Crick in life, he seems like a truly extraordinary man. I look forward to hearing more stories about him!
Comment by Sean - Monday 23rd May 2011 06:54:44 PM

My pleasure to contribute to the immortality of Dr. Crick, although he needs no help. Wonderful to have you blogging also and will surely be cheaper than purchasing more of your books- although I did that also!
Comment by Dr Harimohan - Tuesday 24th May 2011 01:07:31 PM

Dear Sir
I just happened to reach you blog by luck
to read a post on crick by someone who knew him and someone whom every Indian admires and again someone from SMC Chennai ( Iam from KMC Chennai ) was satisfying
looking forwards to many more posts
you work in autism too has great relevance to the mission we are involved in
if and when you have the rare spare time please do click on these links as I would value a response from somebody like you greatly
Thanks again Sir
Dr Harimohan